How to be a good fisherman

We poor anglers. On the bank we’re lost in the prospect of all this water. Where are the fish going to be? How do we stand any chance of catching them? And are we even sure which end of the rod to hold? Never fear, help is at hand, not exactly from a knight in shining armour but certainly a guide in sharp chest waders. As custom for guides comes mainly from insecure fly fishermen, expect the majority to be wearing chest waders. Yet you can expect coarse and sea anglers to be in them too, perhaps following the lead of Mortimer and Whitehouse who pull on a pair just to sit in easy chairs beside a lake.

Apart from modelling waders, what does the fishing guide offer in return for the typical fee of £300 a day? Not how to be good at fishing, that is certain; but a bit of casting instruction, opinion and hand-holding, yes . . . and directing to a few fishy spots with the improved chance of catching something. The last of these is of the most value to an angler who has never seen the water before. It’s a fast track to finding fish, not always easy when the water is unfamiliar, and not necessarily when it is well known. This is the mysterious skill called watercraft or reading the water —the ability to locate the position of fish merely by an insightful gaze at river or lake, a nebulous concept as I’ve mentioned before which allows the ‘expert’ to laud it over the rest of us.

How can you look at the water and tell where the fish are, assuming they’re not showing themselves? The answer is you can’t, or not with any reliability. As with just about everything in fishing, acquired experience is the best guide, far better than, er, a guide’s. Lacking this, ask someone, preferably a fellow angler or a tackle shop who doesn’t relieve you of a few hundred quid for the information. On a chalk stream it’s rarely a problem. To find fish walk to the river. Look into river. See fish and go fishing. If you don’t see fish immediately, walk a few yards until you do. On most other rivers and lakes you can’t see the fish and so it’s more difficult. All the clues have been described at great length in books and articles, and now innumerable videos. They are very simple. Fish want cover and food. In typical trout rivers, where there are many shallows reaches, the deeper water in the main flow is where you usually find the fish, though there are many exceptions. In wide lowland rivers, most of the water is deep, in which case the fish can be anywhere. But still there are deeper scoops that fish seem to prefer; the problem is you can’t see where they are. So it’s back to experience; using plummets and other means to find the lie of the bed helps. No watercraft needed. In the sea you need a boat, an echosounder (and knowledge of wrecks) and many years to find the best fishing spots.

The guide is a shortcut and substitute, not a path to experience. To gain that you have to fish a lot. In other words, to be a good fishermen you have to put in the effort. That presupposes you’re prepared to do that. To be a good fisherman you must want to be a good fisherman. For many that is too much like hard work. For them, fishing is for quiet relaxation, not determined fish catching, and that is all right; I’ve known many happy anglers who hold to that philosophy. Those very few I’ve known who are genuinely good at fishing in comparison to others, I notice one particular facet. They do not copy others, they do not parrot others. When you talk to them their ideas sound fresh and, note, very simple.

Fishing is at heart simple. Trouble is the fish don’t always give that impression. It’s no good looking to guides and competition anglers who are on a quest to become ultra-efficient and all have their own conflicting opinions and methods, none of which confers the wisdom of experience. It’s the difference between being a fisherman and a fish-catching machine. I prefer the first.

The petty and the pitiful

Search ‘fishing’ on YouTube and you’ll get something like 75 million results, last time I checked. How many wasted lives would it take to watch that lot? The swivel-chair fisherman may find enough gigabytes to turn swivel-eyed in whatever time it takes, and my limited perusal of the mind-numbing YT stuff suggests that would be quite short. Young people’s mental health problems from looking at too much online garbage are well documented now but the damage can be done at any age. Enshittification applies to internet fishing material as much as the dancing dog videos, rabid misinformation and all the rest of the dumb stuff filling up the data centres.

Amongst the dross there are some more watchable videos as I mentioned a while ago. But the interest wanes with most. McPhail’s fishing trip films I find too tedious to watch now, although his fly tying demos can be useful, even if better are available, Barry Ord Clarke’s methodical instructions, for example. Yet to read the comments below them, you’d think they were all masterpieces of film-making; all have lots of ‘like’ votes, none have any thumbs-down. The reason has nothing to do with the perceived quality; it’s because the posters of videos disable down-votes, thereby promoting the illusion that everybody loves the output. To ensure there are no dissenters to upset the Eisenstein fantasy, comments are moderated too. Anything beyond ‘what a fantastic video’ are unlikely to appear. There is one excitable chap who posts himself with a poacher’s rod spinning in all kinds of waters, some very remote, accompanied by ‘awesomes’, ‘wows’, ‘come ons’ and ‘get ins’. In one he was almost certainly fishing for trout out of season. I pointed this out in a comment. It did not appear.

Why are there uncountable numbers of fishing videos? Some are part of commercial activity — tackle company advertising, shop windows selling guiding services, for which there is rising demand as a pandemic of chronic fishing incompetence spreads nationwide. Even the pants-wetting blokey mentioned above flogs kit on his website. For many it’s a boastful or attention-seeking vehicle for showing everyone the fish they catch. Some are both. A Yorkshire guide, whom I’m too polite to name, treats viewers to serial trout-catching (using the catch-all-you-can-net method of Euronymphing), highlighting the difference between poor saps elsewhere who’d caught nothing and his couple of dozen so far. His unabashed screen persona, according to those who know him, is a fair reflection of the man. There is another YT poster, also from Yorkshire but strictly amateur, who posts videos of his bending fishing rod. After tipping each fish from the net, the video cuts straight away to another view of ‘fish on’. I only watched to begin with because it was a river I knew a little. I soon hit the back button.

Then there are the techie vids, instructions and discourses on the bits and pieces that go on your line between rod and hook, all contradicting each other to an extent. No matter how banal the information or how bad the presentation, it’s free to post on YouTube, which is the problem: anyone can do it now the digital kit is cheap. The online world is full of junk — present blog excepted of course — and absorbs more and more of people’s time and attention. This is time away from the worthwhile things in life — time with friends, time spent reading a book, going fishing and daydreaming about fishing.

There is something of a backlash developing, other than among those who’ve realised they’re frittering their lives away. I have heard of some clubs who are banning guides from their waters, or introducing rules against filming. On the chalk streams this is not such a problem: access has never been easy for the amateur film maker. It’s different on other waters and the publicity attracted by YT videos and showoff snaps on social media is not welcome.

There’s probably no going back, not at least until the electricity generation capacity is exceeded by the slop’s power demand. Despite my criticisms of fishing magazines, a return to print media might be a good thing. At least there is some filter against the drivel, even if the remaining magazines still love to pretend that all is well in our imperfect world.

Follow @secretangler

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free